I do not know how active I will be on the blog regarding issues concerning Israel and the war that is just getting underway. Security and war-fighting are very much not my specialty, even though I am interested (in more ways than one). I will probably write now and then about these events. To that end, a programming note.
I may lose followers here. I know of at least one person who used to offer valuable comments regularly (on electoral systems) and who stopped doing so after a post about Israeli security some years ago. I know because this person felt the need to tell me so. There may be more to come. I’d prefer you have the courtesy not to tell me so, or to push back in comments or email. Just look away if something offends you, please.
I will note flat out that I’ll have very little patience for criticism of Israel after what has happened. I don’t want a war. But as Kohelet (of which we just had our annual reading in synagogues the day of the Hamas assault) says, there’s a time for war and a time for peace…
(If you aren’t Jewish you know Kohelet as Ecclesiastes.) This is a time for war. There will be civilian casualties in Gaza. None of them will be deliberate goals of IDF actions. And it is important to understand this distinction.
This isn’t about revenge, at least not principally (to be intellectually and emotionally honest, revenge is not itself wrong, depending on how it’s directed). It’s fundamentally about ensuring something like this NEVER AGAIN happens. To that end Hamas must be utterly destroyed. The victims’ families and the rest of society likely will settle for little less after so many were killed. השם יקום דמם . It will be a bumpy ride. So buckle up.
And if my saying this upsets you, please feel free to just stay away for a while. I hope you will come back, or even stay around now for the normal content here but not for posts you are uncomfortable with. It is also important for me to add that comments about specific tactical decisions of the Israeli government or about domestic politics of Israel will always be welcome. If it has not been clear, I am quite disgusted with the current government, and even more so since last Saturday than before. But for now it’s the government Israel has and it (or, please may it be so, a more competent successor) must lead Israel to victory. I just want to be very clear that I don’t wish to engage with anyone whose comments muddy the clarity of distinctions I am expressing here.
Israel will win this war. There is simply no other option. Am Israel chai.