Is Gaza one of the densest places on earth?

I wish I had kept count of the number of times in the last month I have read or heard that “Gaza is one of the densest places on earth”. This statement is usually made without any context whatsoever. (I heard one person on BBC cite an actual figure, but not how it compares to anywhere else.) So is Gaza one of the densest places on earth?

Of course, the answer depends on your definition of “place”. That is, compared to what? The table below compares the Gaza Strip first to several other enclaves, exclaves, or small territories, which would seem to be a relevant comparison group. Then it compares Gaza City itself to several other major urban areas, including a few in the Middle East. While the list of ex/enclaves may be close to exhaustive, obviously the second one is not.

gaza_popdens

The claim is pretty hard to sustain when one checks the facts. In area, the Gaza Strip is similar to Singapore. But the latter is almost four times as densely populated. In terms of density, Gaza is close to Hong Kong (which is overall bigger) and Ceuta and Melilla (which are overall much smaller). But it doesn't seem that Gaza is one of the most densely populated small territorial entities on earth.

So maybe commentators who make this remark mean compared to other urban areas. (I do not think they mean this, because the references always just say "Gaza" in a context that seems to mean the territorial exclave, not a specific city within it, but for the sake of argumentā€¦) Based on the second set of comparisons this, too, looks hard to sustain. Yes, 11 thousand people per square kilometers is dense, but Gaza City is no Baghdad or Cairo or Manhattan.

I am not attempting to make a political point here (I know, hard to believe!). In fact, I have heard apologists for both Hamas tactics and Israel's actions make the claim. As, in "How can Hamas not operate among civilians when Gaza is one of the most densely populated places on earth?" Or "How can Israel avoid killing civilians when Gaza is one of the most densely populated places on earth?"

To be fair, there are specific places within Gaza that are incredibly dense. And some of these are indeed places where Hamas is active, and thus so are they places that the IDF hits hard. For instance, Jabalia has over 1950,000 people in 1.4 sq. km. But again, the media comments I have read and heard do not say "Jabalia is one of the densest places on earth" (and I do not have any idea how it would actually compare with similarly geographically compact locations). They say "Gaza" is. Evidently not.

3 thoughts on “Is Gaza one of the densest places on earth?

  1. One day after my post, the Gatestone Institute asks the same question in the opening line of a posting about Gaza’s open spaces.

    (And, no, I am not generally a fan of Alan Dershowitz, the author of the linked post, but he got this right.)

  2. Well, can be argued that Hong Kong and Singapure are also some of the densest places in Earth; Macau and Mellillla are not goog terms of comparison because they are much small (size matters – if a territory of 360 km^2 has a density of 5000, much probably it will have some sub-territories of 30 km^2 with even higher densities)

    • Well, that’s the point. It depends on your comparative referent, something that is hardly ever mentioned in these offhand statements in the media. And, yes, regarding Hong Kong and Singapore, that is indeed what I was point out: they are much denser.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s