Redo Election in Colombia? (“None of the Above” Wins Indigenous Seat)

Cross-posted from PoliBlog:

In a prior post I discussed the issue of Colombian ballots and noted the fact that voters have the right to check a box entitled voto en blanco which literally translated as “blank vote” or more accurately as “none of the above.”  The average of such votes for Senate elections from 1974-2010, for example, has been 2.58% (as a percentage of all ballots cast).  As such, the historic significance of the voto en blanco has been nothing more than a footnote.

However, in the election for the indigenous set-aside seat for the lower house of Congress, this may not be the case.  Vote Bien is reporting (Elecciones de representante indígena deben repetirse) that the voto en blanco may have won the absolute majority of the votes for the seat, which will obligate the National Electoral Council (CNE) to toss out the candidates who ran and hold new elections with new candidates for the seat.

The story reports that according to the latest bulletin from the National Registry 205,442 valid votes were cast for the seat, and 111,573 were en blanco or 54.3%.

No decision has been made, but once the results are finalized the CNE will meet to determine if a re-vote will take place.

According to the story this happened once before, in a mayoral election in 2003 and the CNE ordered new elections with new candidates.

There is no indication when such an election would take place, although the logical time would be during the presidential elections in May.  However, there is a major problem here, insofar as voting for the indigenous seat is a choice voters make in lieu of voting for representatives from the voter’s Department.  As such, if a new election is held it will have to be open up to all voters (including those who chose to vote for their departmental representation, or for the afro-colombian seat for that matter,  instead of for the indigenous seat), radically changing the nature of the electorate for the seat in question between the two processes.

An example of a Chamber of Representatives ballot is below.  Note that Part C is the indigenous seat and there are a rather large (to understate the situation quite a bit) number of competitors for the seat, meaning not only did a lot of people vote en blanco but that the votes for candidates was quite fragmented.

2010 Bogota

One thought on “Redo Election in Colombia? (“None of the Above” Wins Indigenous Seat)

  1. “None of the above, Nevada’s perpetual ballot loser, lives on after a federal appeals court rejects a Republican-backed lawsuit challenging its constitutionality….”

    – AP, “Court tosses challenge to Nevada’s ‘none’ option,” Las Vegas Sun (10 July 2013) http://tinyurl.com/mutmme5

    “… It’s an asinine anachronism, one that only encourages the mindless vitriol and serial checking-out by too many in the electorate. Yes, let’s make it easier for people not to have to make a choice among candidates, one of whom WILL be elected. If the colloquially named None of the Above actually had teeth – if it finishes first, then a special election is triggered, perhaps – there might be a rationale for it. But it is toothless and, thus, worthless….”

    – jon.ralston, “Ridiculous lawsuit has predictable result, resulting in ridiculous ballot option,” blog (10 July 2013)
    http://tinyurl.com/m9y2l7z

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s